Opens in a new tab
Recent Posts: Indivisible Georgia Coalition

State Calls to Action: DNA Profiles, Criminalizing People Without Homes, and Library Censorship

Please get in touch with your legislators on these two calls to action issued by GLAHR to be followed by a call to action regarding the freedom to read and censorship of our libraries and librarians.

DNA Collection that Expands the Surveillance Apparatus of the State – Oppose

Georgia lawmakers are attacking immigrant communities by expanding unnecessary surveillance of immigrants through DNA collection despite significant privacy concerns. This bill will mandate that increased time, money, and resources be spent on expanding the GBI DNA database and criminalizing immigrants.

What SB 116 Does:

🚨Expands the state’s surveillance apparatus. Current law only requires collection of DNA samples from individuals subject to an immigration detainer notice if they are convicted of a felony. This bill would lower that requirement to individuals subject to an immigration detainer who are charged with a misdemeanor or felony– significantly expanding the state’s DNA database.

🚨DNA profiles are not deleted in cases of government error. While current law does allow for DNA information to be expunged in a narrow set of circumstances, this bill does not mandate expungement for wrongful detainers. This means that DNA profiles could be stored with the GBI even if the detainer was mistaken or the individual is later released from ICE detention.

🚨Expands state targeting of immigrant communities. Current law already requires DNA collection from anyone convicted and sentenced for a felony offense, regardless of whether they are subject to an immigration detainer. This bill singles out immigrants charged with misdemeanors and felonies for additional DNA collection based on the issuance of an immigration detainer, which can be erroneous.

🚨 Contributes to further criminalization of Black and immigrant communities. Aggressive immigration enforcement is often used as a vehicle to expand state repression. Due to racial profiling and discriminatory policing practices, this bill will result in an increase in DNA profiles connected to Black and immigrant communities.

🚨 Diverts funding from our communities. An individual charged with a misdemeanor traffic violation could be subject to an immigration detainer request and have their DNA collected under this bill. This will only exacerbate the existing DNA analysis backlog. Rather than spending money on supporting our communities, this bill will require increased funding for collecting and analyzing additional DNA profiles.

🚨Raises significant privacy concerns. DNA profiles contain inherently sensitive information, from health information and ancestry to predictive data indicating predispositions to certain illnesses or behaviors. This information, once collected, will be accessible to any local, state, or federal law enforcement agency pursuant to any official criminal investigation.

What is an immigration detainer request?

  • Immigration detainers, also known as “ICE detainers,” are voluntary requests from ICE to local law enforcement agencies to notify ICE when an individual is due to be released and detain the individual for up to an additional 48 hours to facilitate transfer to ICE custody. Georgia law mandates that law enforcement officers and jailers comply with immigration detainers. An immigration detainer is not proof that an individual has violated any federal immigration law. ICE databases often contain errors leading to erroneous detainer requests being issued for U.S. citizens, lawful permanent residents, and visa-holders.

    Use this link to send a note to your elected offical.


The Criminalization of Those Without Homes Providing No Solution – Oppose

Georgia legislators are launching an attack on our most vulnerable communities punishing people who are unhoused, people who have mental health or addiction concerns, and immigrant communities. Instead of providing much needed funding and resources to support these communities, HB 295 aims to further dehumanize and criminalize them.

What HB 295 Does:

🚨 Incentivizes enforcement of laws that criminalize the homeless population instead of providing real solutions like allocating funds for housing or mental health services.

🚨 Emboldens vigilantism by allowing individuals to submit a claim to their local government if they believe their local government is not dealing with vulnerable people in ways that they deem acceptable and demanding reimbursement for expenses they incur taking matters into their own hands.

🚨 Forces local governments to create harsh local immigration policies just to preempt claims that they have enacted a sanctuary policy.

🚨 Wastes local resources responding to frivolous claims for compensation from individuals. The bill mandates local governments to respond within 30 days by accepting or rejecting the individual’s claim for compensation.

🚨Clogs up the court system by creating a right of action for individuals to sue localities if the local government doesn’t respond within 30 days or if the local government rejects the individual’s claim for compensation.  

🚨 Forces localities to quickly and recklessly adopt harmful policies in order to avoid facing claims of failing to enforce existing laws or of maintaining a public nuisance.

🚨Creates an environment of fear that further ostracizes certain communities.

Please use this link to contact your elected official.

S.B. 74 – The Freedom to Read and the Freedom to Be a Librarian Without Being Criminalized. 

We have additional talking points to add to our original post on this bill.  

Here are five simple reasons this bill should (again) be dropped:

⁃ Library books are not how children are exposed to pornography. This is patently ridiculous. Children access sexual content through their phones and through their friends’ phones. And they bypass internet filters with ease, so if they don’t have phones, they access it through their school-issued laptops. It’s that simple.

⁃ No librarian would ever distribute pornography to children, but libraries do contain balanced and widely varied collections of fiction and non-fiction materials. This balance means that some materials inevitably run counter to the political agenda of some activists. This bill does nothing to protect children, but it does pave the way for highly partisan, life-ruining attacks on dedicated librarians who just want children to be literate.

⁃ There is no way to enforce this law in the real world. Are we going to prosecute the person who checked the offending book out to the child? What if that person is a paraprofessional, a student aide, a substitute, or a volunteer? What if the library has self-checkout? Or are we going to prosecute the librarian who purchased the book? What if it was bought 15 years ago and the librarian has long since retired? If we plan to prosecute the librarian who is currently responsible for the collection, do we expect each librarian to evaluate 10,000 or so books (against an ill-defined standard) before they open circulation? And will this process begin again every time a new librarian is hired? In the libraries with more than one librarian, which one will we prosecute?

⁃ Georgia DOE has just rolled out a new English curriculum with a huge emphasis on independent reading. This curriculum cannot be implemented without access to robust school library collections. If school librarians have to fear politically-motivated criminal prosecution, they will be forced to eliminate all but a few books, and this curriculum will fail.

⁃ Similar laws in other states have already been struck down in court. Passing this law will inevitably lead to a protracted and very expensive legal battle, and we should not waste tax dollars fighting to defend a law that attempts to solve a problem that does not exist.

Please encourage friends and family to contact Rules members and their own reps as well. If you watch the other hearings, you’ll see that other groups are activated to push for the bill’s passage (AND that truth is optional on their part).

Tuesday subcommittee hearing video

Thursday hearing video

Call your own state representative and demand that they protect librarians and oppose S.B.74. Libraries are a vital part of each community and librarians are public servants who are trained to do their jobs. After that call, please call the members of this committee again. Thank you for taking action and sharing with others. 


Call and Email Committee Members

NameEmailPhonePosition
Tyler Paul Smith[email protected](404) 463-7853Chair
Stan Gunter[email protected](404) 656-5125Ex-Officio
Charlice Byrd[email protected](404) 656-0213Member
Chuck Efstration[email protected](404) 656-5052Member
Clint Crowe[email protected](404) 656-0325Member
Dar’shun Kendrick[email protected](404) 656-0126Member
El-Mahdi Holly[email protected](404) 656-0287Member
Esther Panitch[email protected](404) 656-0287Member
James Burchett[email protected](404) 656-5024Member
Joseph Gullett[email protected](404) 463-2248Member
Rob Leverett[email protected](404) 656-5132Member
Sharon Cooper[email protected](404) 656-5069Member
Shea Roberts[email protected](404) 656-0298Member
Yasmin Neal[email protected](404) 656-6372Member
Soo Hong[email protected](404) 651-7737Secretary
Deborah Silcox[email protected](404) 657-1803Vice-Chair