Opens in a new tab
Recent Posts: Indivisible Georgia Coalition

Georgia Legislature: Freedom of Assembly, Freedom of Speech Under Attack

ACLU responds to SB 359—making protest(s) a RICO violation
Summary:  This bill seeks to make various disfavored protest activities, irrespective of their constitutionally protected status, prosecutable under Georgia’s RICO statute by greatly expanding the scope of Georgia’s hate crime law and making any violation of that statute a violation of Georgia’s RICO statute.  In plain English, this bill has the potential to disallow peaceful protests, distribution of literature, and other commonly used advocacy tactics.

History: 
Georgia has a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations {RICO} Statute which, like its Federal cousin, was largely passed to combat organized crime as in the Mafia.  As we are aware with DA Fani Willis’ indictments against Atlanta Public School educators in the past and Trump and company in the present.  The major difference between the federal law and Georgia’s law is that Georgia’s law is much broader and does not always require the existence of a racketeering enterprise.  Racketeering activity can include any act or threat involving serious crimes (murder, kidnapping, arson, drug dealing, to name only a few crimes.  Violations of Georgia’s RICO statute are punishable by imprisonment of between 5 and 20 years or a fine or both.  Georgia’s Hate Crime Statute creates a sentencing enhancement for the commission of felony offenses or designated misdemeanors if it is determined by a trial or guilty plea that the defendant selected any victim or group of victims or any property as the object of the offense because of such victim’s actual or perceived race, color, religion, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender, mental disability or physical disability.  Establishing the presence of such bias means the defendant’s sentence will be increased over what it would have been without the established bias.

The New Law under SB 359:
Section 3 of the bill expands Georgia’s hate crime statute so the following misdemeanors will be predicate offenses (along with all felonies): simple assault; simple battery; battery; criminal trespass; littering; placement of posters, signs, and advertisements; theft by taking; disorderly or disruptive conduct with the intent to interfere with the orderly conduct of any funeral or memorial service; loitering or prowling; terroristic threats; disorderly conduct; harassing communications. Additionally, the bill adds “political affiliation or beliefs” to the protected classes in the scope of the hate crime law. Therefore, under the bill, if anyone commits any felony or the enumerated misdemeanors above against a person because of their political affiliation or beliefs they must have their sentence enhanced. Interestingly, the potential for prosecuting political bias was specifically criticized by the Georgia Supreme Court when that court struck down Georgia’s prior hate crime statute.  Further, the text of the bill in Section 2 appears to subject individuals to RICO liability for a single violation of Georgia’s hate crime statute, which does not comport with the legislative intent of the state’s RICO law. 

Finally, this bill purports not to diminish or infringe upon the First Amendment or an individual’s right to legally protected conduct or expressive activity pertaining to any matter of United States foreign or domestic policy or international affairs. Interestingly, there is no such allowance for protected conduct or expressive activity pertaining to policies of the State of Georgia or its political subdivisions.  

ACLU of Georgia Recommendation:
The ACLU of Georgia strongly opposes this bill. Civil disobedience is fundamental to the people’s ability to effectively petition their Government, especially when decisions by the state cannot be effectively addressed through ballot box accountability. Georgia recognized that by expressly stating Georgia’s RICO statute will not be used to prosecute single misdemeanor acts or acts of civil disobedience. Inexplicably this law expressly weaponizes Georgia’s RICO statute to do both.  Protest is not always pretty and the state will often vehemently disagree with the views of hose protesting. Neither of those facts justify subjecting protesters to 20 years in prison for their expressive conduct. Both the United States and Georgia constitutions, not to mention base notions of good governance and due process, demand otherwise.A bill introduced in the Georgia Senate would greatly expand the list of crimes that could be prosecuted under the state’s RICO statute.

Why it matters: People handing out fliers, littering, disorderly conduct or loitering could face stiffer penalties and RICO charges if the proposal were to become law.

Driving the news: Senate Bill 359, sponsored by state Sen. John Albers, passed the Senate Judiciary Committee on Monday.

Some of the “designated misdemeanors” that could be classified as patterns of racketeering include criminal trespass, littering, distributing posters, signs and leaflets in restricted areas, disrupting a funeral or memorial service, and loitering or prowling.

The legislation also allows for enhanced penalties for a defendant if a victim was targeted due to their political beliefs or affiliations.

What they’re saying: Albers, a Republican from Roswell, told committee members that the legislation is “fairly simple in its desire to make sure that people who are committing these heinous acts are held accountable for their crimes.”

Yes, but: State Sen. Ed Setzler (R-Acworth) said he wants to see the legislation tweaked so people handing out political leaflets are not charged with racketeering. “I don’t think that’s a RICO enterprise,” he said.

The other side: Grant Park resident Lisa Magee, who has protested Atlanta’s public safety training center, said she felt like the legislation is “directed specifically at people in my organizing community.”

“Whether or not you agree about what the protest is for, or what the fliers says, [or] what political bias you think is the motivating factor, these actions should not be lumped into racketeering and conspiracy charges,” Magee said.

What we’re watching: The bill will most likely be tweaked and amended as it goes through the General Assembly.

What’s next: S.B. 359 will be placed on the calendar for a Senate floor vote. To find your state senator visit https://pluralpolicy.com/find-your-legislator/ Call or write to ask them to oppose SB359.